We show that dislocations in active 2d smectics with underlying rotational symmetry are always unbound in the presence of noise, meaning the active smectic phase does not exist for non-zero noise in $d=2$. The active smectic phase can, like equilibrium smectics in 2d, be stabilized by applying rotational symmetry breaking fields; however, even in the presence of such fields, active smectics are still much less stable against noise than equilibrium ones, when the symmetry breaking field(s) are weak.
Comment: 23 pages, 3 figures