Outcomes based on menopausal status of breast cancer (BC) patients who are BRCA mutations carriers (BRCAm) are not well known. A prospective database identified 88 BRCAm with BC from 2005 to 2015. Of the 88 patients, 68 (77.3%) women were premenopausal (Pre-M) and 20 (22.7%) were postmenopausal (Post-M). In the Pre-M group, 52.9 per cent of patients had triple-negative (TN) BC, whereas in the Post-M group, there were more estrogen receptor +(65%; P = 0.129) and less TN (25%; P = 0.041) tumors. Median tumor size was significantly larger in the Pre-M group compared with the Post-M group (P <0.001). Pre-M women were more likely to present with stage III cancers (14.7% vs 0%, respectively, P = 0.082). Ten-year overall survival was 87.9 per cent in the Pre-M group and 93.8 per cent in the Post-M group (P = 0.44), and 25.3 per cent of Pre-M women had recurrences compared with 11.5 per cent of Post-M women (P = 0.24). Premenopausal BRCAm with BC are more likely to have TN, higher stage disease, and twice the number of recurrences at 10 years than Post-M BRCAm. Our study is the first to show worse BC outcomes for Pre-M BRCAm compared with Post-M BRCAm women. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]