Abstract Objectives Age‐related hearing loss (presbycusis) is a prevalent condition traditionally attributed to inner ear dysfunction. Little is known about age‐related changes in the ossicular joints or their contribution to presbycusis. Herein, we performed an otopathologic evaluation of the ossicular joints in cases of presbycusis without a clear sensorineural explanation. Methods Histopathologic analysis of the incudomallear (IM) and incudostapedial (IS) joints was performed in specimens from the National Temporal Bone Registry with audiometrically confirmed presbycusis but without histologically observed sensorineural, strial, or mixed features; deemed cases of “indeterminate” presbycusis. Specimens identified as “indeterminate” presbycusis (IP, n = 18) were compared to specimens with histologically confirmed sensorineural presbycusis (n = 16) and strial presbycusis (n = 11). Presbycutic specimens were also compared to age‐matched controls (n = 9) and young controls (n = 14). Results The synovial space at the center of the IM joint was wider in the IP group (194 ± 36.8 μm) compared to age‐matched controls (138 ± 36.5 μm), young controls (149 ± 32.2 μm), and ears with sensorineural presbycusis (148 ± 52.7 μm) (p