Phyllobacterium myrsinacearum is an organism not previously described as causing infections in humans. We report the case of a 63-year-old gentleman who presented with breathlessness, reduced Glasgow Coma Scale and septic shock requiring intensive care unit admission. Whilst CT imaging showed a severe pneumonia, it also revealed findings consistent with an L1–2 discitis. The biopsy of this spinal disc revealed the above organism on 16S rDNA Real-Time PCR. Having initially thought this may be a contaminant, extensive step-wise review of the processing of the sample suggested this was likely to be a true finding and left us with a number of questions such as how did it get there, what was the optimal antibiotic regimen and how long to treat it for?