Most of the electrocatalytic processes of interest in the resolution of modern energy challenges are associated with proton transfer. In the cases where heavy atom bond cleavage occurs concomitantly, the question arises of the exact nature of its coupling with proton–electron transfer within the catalytic cycle. The cleavage of a C–O bond in the catalyzed electrochemical conversion of CO2 to CO offers the opportunity to address this question. Electrochemically generated iron(0) porphyrins are efficient, specific, and durable catalysts provided they are coupled with Lewis or Brönsted acids. The cocatalyst properties of four Brönsted acids of increasing strength, water, trifluoroethanol, phenol, and acetic acid, have been systematically investigated. Preparative-scale electrolyses showed that carbon monoxide is the only product of the catalytic reaction. Methodic application of a nondestructive technique, cyclic voltammetry, with catalyst and CO2 concentrations, as well as H/D isotope effect, as diagnostic parameters allowed the dissection of the reaction mechanism. It appears that the key step of the reaction sequence consists of an electron transfer from the catalyst concerted with the cleavage of a C–O bond and the transfer of one proton. This is the second example, and an intermolecular version of such a concerted proton–electron bond-breaking reaction after a similar electrochemical process involving the cleavage of O–O bonds has been identified. It is the first time that a proton–electron transfer concerted with bond breaking has been uncovered as the crucial step in a catalytic multistep reaction. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]